Best Closed Toe Water Sandals

Sandals definitely serve the convenience of both worlds- protection of your feet and maximized relaxation of being barefoot. Closed toe sandals are bracing and freeing and are a ‘must have’ especially during summer. They offer all the comfort that common sandals cannot, and they are certainly more stylish and fancier. They feature cutouts which keep most of the foot exposed and also provide protection and support for wanderlusts who love long-distance walks.

Nonetheless, these sandals are certainly not the type of footwear you can take out to the wild because they are not designed for rugged environments. Closed toe sandals are best reserved for lazy days to the beach, around the pool, to the city, or an after-hike bonfire. They are the best outdoor sandals because they have an excellent foot grip and buffer your toes from roadside falling debris. However, they are not as flexible as open-toed sandals though they are long lasting. 

Product Name

Price Range

Our Rating

Buy

Merrell Hydro Water Sandal

$$

4.8/5

Teva Women’s Omnium Sandal

$$$

4.7/5

KEEN Women’s Bali Strap Sandal

$$$

4.8/5

KEEN Men’s Newport H2 Sandal

$$$

4.6/5

New Balance Men’s Appalachian Closed-Toe Sandal

$$ 4.4/5

Merrell Hydro Water Sandal

Features

  • Protective wrap-up toe guard for your toes.
  • Vented upper for fresh air.
  • Decorative bungee lacing.
  • Adjustable hook-and-loop closure.

Pros

  • Great lacing system that makes the shoe beautiful and colorful.
  • Dry quickly so you can get in the water with them.
  • They have treads on their sole increasing their grip on wet and slippery surfaces.
  • Have thick and stiff soles.

Cons

  • The sole wears out quickly if frequently worn.
  • Friction between the feet and the rubber causing blisters especially at the back of the legs.
  • The openings might let in little rocks, which can be painful to step on.

Product overview

This is a typical water shoe that can be worn to the beach or around the swimming pool. The upper part of the sandal is 100% leather making it waterproof. Merrell Girls’ Hydro H2O Hiker Sandal, Grey/Turquoise, 060 Medium US Big Kid have a strong quick-pull bungee lace system that comes in handy when you want to adjust the wrap by tightening or loosening it. The lacing system also has an adjustable hook closure. Since the lacing is stitched, they can be made in various colors. The thick rubber sole makes the sandal suitable for hiking in rocky places because you will not feel sharp rocks under your feet. The sandals’ sole also has treads on their sole making their grip on wet surfaces strong.


Teva Women’s Omnium Sandal

Features

  • The heel is estimated to be approximately 1 1/4″
  • Has the letter W to show it is for women.
  • 100% synthetic mesh and sole.
  • Grosgrain webbing overlays.

Pros

  • Reasonable price.
  • Suitable for both land and water.
  • Traction rubber outsole.
  • Shock absorbing ShocPad technology in heel.

Cons

  • The decorative bungee lacing can be useless if the calm holding fails.
  • Can be slightly narrow and tight at the opening.
  • Takes a while to dry out so it can get smelly.

Product Overview

The Teva Women Omnium sandals are designed for hiking but are open on the upper part to resemble a sandal. This makes the shoes multi-occasional and suitable for everyday use. They are comfortable and soft since they are made of rubber and synthetic textile.

The amazing thing is that they have Shoc-pads mechanism on their heels which prevents any rocks or sharp objects from hurting your feet. The rubber toe bumper shields your big toe from being hurt when you run into sharp objects. Therefore, you can hike in these shoes and do other outdoor activities. The Teva textile synthetic uppers are durable and easy to maintain. The adjustable front traps are secured to the sandal with a plastic buckle so there is no chance it can come undone.


KEEN Women’s Bali Strap Sandal

Features

  • Synthetic sol.e
  • Hydrophobic mesh lining.
  • Metatomical EVA footbed.
  • Heel measures approximately 0.75 inches.

Pros

  • Non-making rubber sole.
  • Lightweight and breathable for your feet.
  • Protect your toes from getting hurt or wet.
  • They are not noisy when you walk.

Cons

  • Slippery on wet surfaces.
  • Stitching issues.
  • It is narrow in the toe box, so if you have wide feet, you might need to order up.

Product Overview

It goes without saying; the Keen Women’s Bali Strap-W Sandal, Black/Steel Grey, 8 M US women’s Bali strap sandal is both sporty and elegant. Their design makes them feminine specific, and the quality is just impeccable. Let’s start with the front; it is patented offering your foot protection. The sandal has a multi-directional lug pattern on the sole for sturdier traction which increases the shoe’s grip.

Unlike the male version, the female sandal has an open space on the upper part making the sandal breathable and allowing air circulation when it so hot. This avoids sweaty and smelly feet. The rear pull-on loop is flexible and easy to just slip in and out of the sandal. There is also the fact that the sandals are machine washable which makes them even more endearing. 


KEEN Men’s Newport H2 Sandal

Features

  • Washable polyester webbing.
  • Metatomical EVA footbed.
  • Multi-directional lug pattern for increased traction
  • Secure fit lace capture system.

Pros

  • Machine washable.
  • Toe protection.
  • Sporty design.

Cons

  • The stitching is not the best quality and wears out quickly.
  • The heel strap is not adjustable.

Product Overview

Keen Men’s Newport H2 sandal has a curvy design and a thick EVA midsole which provides protection and stability. As a keen loyalist, the variety of colors is among the reasons that make you run to the store to get a pair. The sandals provide great support especially on uneven terrain, making the shoes perfect for hiking. Also, its quick drying quality has made the sandals popular.

All in all, KEEN Men’s Newport H2 Sandal, Raven/Aluminum, 10.5 M US Newport H2 sandals can be considered among the must-haves because they are lightweight footwear with exceptional traction. The Metatomical footbed feature is exclusive only to keen brands. It is a design that outlines the insole as a foot shape with emphasis on the first metatarsal joint.


New Balance Men’s Appalachian Closed-Toe Sandal

Features

  • Has a rubber sole.
  • The shaft is approximated to be 2.38” from the arch.
  • Rubber toe bumper.
  • Has a fixed blackstrap and a stretchy bungee lacing.

Pros

  • Sporty design.
  • Durable for high-wear areas.
  • Bungee lacing conveniently helps in adjusting the fitting.
  • Not expensive.

Cons

  • Lacing will not adjust if the slider lock fails.
  • When it’s hot, it can make your feet sweat.
  • The string code stretches out after a while.

Product Overview

The New Balance Men’s Appalachian Sandal, Black/Orange, 11 4E US men’s Appalachian is a heavy-duty sandal which is durable, high quality, and classy. It is a closed- toe look-alike of sneakers with a fixed toe blackstrap, bungee lacing, and a rubber toe bumper. The thick sole rubber made of a blend of Lycra and polyurethane is both comfortable and supportive. The midsole is a compression of EVA, which eliminates the possibility of footsore.

If you are worried about size and color, the brand is diverse in both perspectives. The Appalachian also comes with Ndurance technology, which maximizes durability, especially in high wear areas. This makes the sandal suitable for outdoor activities such as short trips and excursions.


Final Thoughts

Closed toe sandals are not necessarily the first choice of footwear because they are not flashy or fancy. Unlike dress sandals and flip-flops, closed-toe hiking sandals are designed with thick rubber soles for support and cushioning. The underline features you should look out for when getting a closed toe sandal are: Toe bumpers, tough outsole, quality upper straps, cushion, and abrasion resistance.

There are two things that are common among closed toe sandals: How much traction the outsole of the shoe has and how the uppers are designed. Water-friendly sandals do not have uppers that get soaked, and if they do, they dry up quickly. This is the opposite for dry terrain sandals. Nonetheless, almost all closed toes sandals have open uppers. Great traction allows you to walk on slippery terrain because of the soles’ firm grip. Even so, a great sporty sandal has excellent adhesion on both the inner and the outer sole of the sandal.

Just like any other footwear, it is also hard to get the right sandal size. Most closed toe sandals are narrow with high arches; therefore, if you are in-between sizes, it might be hard to get your size.

Another similar characteristic of the sandals is that they do not open fully but have adjustable traces and straps. However, most of them are stretchy to allow you to slide in and out easily. As a result, you might need to push your foot all the way through the opening. I assume this might not be convenient if you are in a hurry.

Polyester, wedding, and synthetics are some of the materials that are used to make closed toe sandals washable. However, leather does not need cleaning, wiping with a towel and some cream or oil could be all the maintenance they need.

Tips to consider before Choosing a Pair of Sandals

  • First things first, how much are you willing to spend on the pair of sandal? Find a pair that is within your price range.
  • You have to consider the occasion you are going to. There are sandals for wet areas like the beach and there are sandals for hiking.
  • Research by reading as many reviews as you can on the sandals you want. Do not get just two or three reviews. Get as many opinions and feedback as you can so you make the best choice.
  • You have to consider the quality of the sandals you want to buy. You do not want to get a pair of sandals that spoil with three or four trips to the beach or out hiking.
  • Comfort and style should also dictate the type of sandals you should get.
  • Maintenance of the sandals.

Product Name

Price Range

Our Rating

Buy

Merrell Hydro Water Sandal

$$

4.8/5

Teva Women’s Omnium Sandal

$$$

4.7/5

KEEN Women’s Bali Strap Sandal

$$$

4.8/5

KEEN Men’s Newport H2 Sandal

$$$

4.6/5

New Balance Men’s Appalachian Closed-Toe Sandal

$$ 4.4/5